Categories
Uncategorized

Conley’s Corner February 2024

I was recently speaking with a prospect and he said: “We have a great practice concept and offices in Fairhope and Huntsville which are great locations…why can’t we find someone?”

We get this question a lot and I generally have the same answer: It’s not you. It’s the market…don’t beat yourself up.  After 25 years of physician search, I don’t know that there has ever been a more difficult market to recruit physicians.

 

Here’s why:

  • The demand for physicians has never been higher.
    • As physicians age, they are retiring out of medicine and need to be replaced. A generally good stock market has kept retirement savings safe allowing the baby boomer generation of physicians to retire (or slow down and work part-time or do locums).
    • Private equity is flowing into healthcare presently creating new models of delivery, especially in primary care. These organizations are looking for physicians who do procedures, make referrals and see patients. These start ups are actively recruiting physicians.
    • The baby boomer generation, the largest population mass in the US, is roughly 80 years old to 60 years old. These patients access healthcare more than any other grouping.
  • Covid has had lasting effect on the physician search market.
    • Interest rates have increased to levels not seen in years. This makes selling a higher priced home more expensive as well as buying a home more expensive.

So, what do we do about it?  As I also tell our clients, unfortunately this is the world that we live in and you can’t do anything about it.  What you can impact is how you respond to this market.  Having the correct approach to recruiting and getting it right has never been more important.  Here are some things to consider as you are recruiting:

  • Start with the mindset that I get one shot at it so when you identify an interested candidate, you have to get everything right.  I spoke with a candidate today about an opportunity with a client which he expressed interest in.  He quickly reminded me that “I have other offers that I am considering as well as this.”  They won’t always offer this information to you, but trust that they have other options on the table.
    • Have a plan after the interview to follow up with candidates to gain feedback and make an offer as appropriate. Respond when the memory of your opportunity is fresh in their mind rather than allow the candidate to continue interviewing.
  • Focus on candidates that are within your region. In the last few years, candidates have reconsidered their professional goals and their current role may not fit as well as it did a few years ago. Those candidates may not wish to relocate but are interested in a new opportunity.
    • If you have changed something in your opportunity (better compensation, better call, etc.) advertise that to local candidates. This may be a way to catch the interest of a local candidate.
  • Think about resident and fellowship candidates who will complete their training in 2025 or 2026. With our aging physician workforce, those physicians may not meet your current need but they can address your future needs. If you have the ability to provide a stipend, you may be able to secure one of these candidates. You may find candidate who is planning to return to your region and you can get a jump on the competition.
  • Lastly, remember that your physicians and providers are your competitors’ targets. With the new year, take the time to ensure your current team is happy and satisfied and work to address as needed.
    • Too often, we get the call when three OBGYN s or GIs have left due to an issue rather than when the issue was first identified. Replacing one physician is far simpler and less expensive than replacing multiple physicians so address those concerns early on.

I hope this information is helpful to you and your team and we are always available to discuss by phone specific questions or issues that you may have.  Good luck!

Categories
Uncategorized

Conley’s Corner July 2023

The end of June signals the halfway point in 2023 and is great time to look back on the first half of the year and the trends that we saw in physician recruiting.  Here are some of our takeaways:

  • Primary care is still highly pursued as health systems are actively recruiting primary care physicians to ultimately replace those retiring. Almost half of the family medicine physician population are 55 and older.
    • Hospitals and health systems are recruiting primary care physicians to partner with existing Advanced Practice Providers (APP). All States have unique rules regarding supervision of an APP and organizations are maximizing their primary care physicians. Specialties like psychiatry are also actively using APPS to provide care,
  • We have seen hospital clients implement new care models using advanced practice providers to cover inpatient and/or emergency department to relieve primary care physicians from these responsibilities.
  • In Q2, we saw two providers of physician services, envision and American Physician Partners, face financial challenges. These organizations provide hospitalist and ED staffing in hospitals and health systems. It will be interesting to see how these services will be replaced, either by hospitals employing these physicians, a private group or taking over at these facilities, or another national organization stepping into these facilities.
  • Ob/Gyn continues to be a highly demanded specialty and a surprisingly difficult recruitment. 48% of Ob/Gyns are 55 or older and Ob/Gyns tend to gravitate away from obstetrics and focus on gynecology as they age. This puts the onus on practice groups and hospital groups to recruit Ob/Gyns to replace those retiring or stepping away from obstetrics. Ob/Gyn recruitment is also affected by the demand for laborists which are drawn from the overall Ob/Gyn population.
  • Psychiatry remains a highly demanded specialty with the emphasis on outpatient care and less so inpatient care.
  • In the world of medical subspecialties, gastroenterology is a frequently requested specialty for recruitment. Cardiology, primarily non-invasive cardiology, seems to also be highly demanded.
  • Surgical specialties have not been requested at the same level as the aforementioned specialties. Urology continues to be one of the more sought-after surgical specialties as well as vascular surgery.
  • Radiology is the hospital-based specialty most frequently requested by our clients.
  • Lastly, the remaining effects of COVID and the rising interest rates have had a big impact on the physician recruitment market. Physicians are less likely to relocate than in past years, which has impacted recruiting.
Categories
Uncategorized

Competing Financially With A Candidate – Part 2

Part 2 –

Continued…

So, how do you compete in this environment if your salary is not as attractive as other offers?  Well, here are a few pointers that I have seen work over the years.

  • Once you have a good objective evaluation of your practice, identify the components of your opportunity that you can enhance. Look for areas of your opportunity where you can truly stand out and be best of class.  It’s hard to be all things for all people but identify an area where your offering can stand out and market that to potential candidates.
  • If your practice can’t offer the best financial opportunity, focus on offering a great quality of life. Many physicians are attracted to this and a 4-day work week, minimal call, etc. are attractive to candidates and can be a difference maker for candidates seeking a better quality of life.
  • Understand the true cost of a physician opening – If you have a physician opening, what are you doing fill that role in the interim? What are the potential costs (financial and otherwise) of not filling a position?  We recently spoke with a client about the dollars they are spending on locums’ coverage and realized they could pay more salary than they originally planned.  Often the cost savings will cover the increase in salary
  • Candidate pool – Look for opportunities to expand your candidate pool, potentially with experienced candidates or part-time candidates. Many psychiatrists are looking for 2 to 3 days of work to supplement a private practice and a couple of part time candidates may replace a full-time candidate.
  • A Physician once shared with me that his career could be divided into three phases – Your learning years where you learn the practice of medicine and ramp up; your earning years where a physician can maximize his/her income; and your legacy years where a physician focuses on giving back, possibly in a health clinic or an academic setting. Be sure to look out for the candidates who are in the legacy phase of their career.
  • Be committed to recruiting and outwork the competition – This means when engaging with prospective candidates, move with purpose and efficiency including following up with candidates, setting interviews and most importantly extending offers. If you give candidates time to find a higher salaried offer, they will likely find one so be timely with your offers.
  • Candidates will be able to identify the shortcomings of your opportunity on their own so don’t belabor these points with candidates. Know your strengths and let candidates know what makes you strong. Emphasize the positive!

 

 

  • Lastly, I always remind candidates who wants them to take more money…the Government. If a candidate makes more money, they pay more in taxes.  Always remember that the difference in compensation between positions is taxed and not fully realized by the candidate.

I hope these points are helpful to you and we are always available to discuss in detail your current situation.

Categories
Uncategorized

Competing Financially With A Candidate – Part 1

Part 1 –

I have had the opportunity to work with FQHC clients over the years and have always enjoyed helping those clients. A common hurdle that they face, as do many academic and other practices, is competing financially when making an offer to a candidate.  Sure, there are those candidates who are mission-minded or looking to give back (more on this later) or enjoy teaching, but more and more physicians are looking for the best salary that they can find. 

So, how do you compete in this environment if your salary is not as attractive as other offers?  Well, here are a few pointers that I have seen work over the years.

  • Start with a good objective evaluation of your opportunity. Understand your strengths as well as the areas that you may lag vs. competitors in the marketplace. Sure, this will likely include compensation but may include other areas as well. Some categories to consider include:
    • Benefit package – CME, PTO or vacation, malpractice insurance, retirement
      • I have a client that offers a 6% retirement match which can equate to $18k per year which is tax deferred…do you have an offering like this?
    • Salary – Is it guaranteed? For how long? Many salaries today are for 1-2 years and then wRVU compensation plan takes over.
    • Additional compensation – Is a productivity bonus available? Quality bonus? Supervision bonus? When is this bonus available to a new hire? Many times these bonuses aren’t available for 2 or more years so the impact to candidates is diluted.
    • Sign on/Commencement bonus? Retention bonus? Training stipend?
      • If you are a private physician group, these types of bonuses are where local hospitals often contribute to a group’s recruiting efforts. If you haven’t had those discussions with your local hospital, you should consider.
    • Educational loan repayment – Do you offer this? Are you eligible for NHSC program? Have you registered?  Many practices that are eligible for NHSC loan program have not applied.
    • Community- What does your community offer? Get input from people on your team who are not originally from the area.  Why did they move here? What do they like about living here? 
    • Region – Understand your overall region (roughly a 1-to-2-hour radius). Your community may be a small rural location, but access to
    • Patient/procedure volume expected – This impacts quality of life.
    • Call and coverage – Physicians look at call and coverage in terms of frequency as well as severity. How does your position compare?
    • Support – RN? NP/PA?
Categories
Uncategorized

Challenging Times with Physician Recruitment

The physician recruitment market continues to be challenging, with specialties like urology, ob/gyn and psychiatry being particularly difficult.  Because groups and health centers are actively recruiting to fill these types of searches, I encourage all of you to continue to focus on the retention of your current medical staff/team.  Remember, your medical staff is the target of communities actively seeking those specialties.

In those hard-to-find specialties, your physicians and providers are being bombarded by opportunities every day. I spoke with a urologist yesterday who told me he receives 10 job solicitations daily which I am sure is not uncommon.  Additionally, if you are actively recruiting for a specialty, then your current physicians are likely being stressed by additional call in the absence of a physician.  Before losing one of your physicians, take steps to ensure better retention of your medical staff.

Retention has never been more important for physician groups and medical staffs due to this environment.  Here are some things I have learned over the years regarding retention:

  • Physicians are most vulnerable to departing your community in the first two years. After two years, physicians and their spouses (and their kids) have established roots in the community and are much more likely to remain in your community through the everyday ups and downs of the practice of medicine. Therefore, the focus on retention needs to start from day 1 the physician is in your community and really before they ever arrive.
  • When devising compensation, try to keep this two-year window in mind. The sooner physicians are maximizing their compensation, the more likely they are to settle in.
  • Empathy is critical to identifying physicians who are susceptible to leaving your community. When we talk to physicians who are relocating, it is often brought on by some form of change. When change occurs, identify those vulnerable physicians, and have a talk with them.
  • Retention bonuses are a good way to have physicians remain to earn/receive bonuses after the end of year 1 and 2.
  • The average age of physicians has never been higher with physicians actively working in their 50s and 60s. Physicians of this age group are often empty nesters and therefore are not susceptible to some of the children issues that cause physicians to relocate like quality of schools. Broaden your target market to include these physicians when recruiting.
  • Physicians relocate for personal as well as professional reasons, maybe more for personal reasons. The personal component means the entire family including spouse and children. It is often easier for the physician to settle into your community because they have a work family from Day 1 but with so many people working remotely, the spouse may be working from home without a social network. Look for ways to get the spouse and children involved in the community. Many organizations have groups in place to help spouses transition to a community and this can be a great resource if you don’t already have this in place.

I hope these points are helpful to you and we are always available to discuss in detail your current situation.

Categories
Uncategorized

Recruitment is a commitment

Recruitment is rarely, if ever convenient.  That’s just the way it is.  You are going to have to make phone calls at night, go to dinner events on Thursday or Friday night, and spend your Friday afternoon touring a candidate through the hospital.  It takes time and the results will not always be what you hope they will be.  But, if you are committed to the search and work efficiently and expeditiously, you are much more likely to have a successful outcome sooner and begin to enjoy the benefit of adding a new colleague to the team.

Categories
Uncategorized

Healthcare Staffing Shortage

Definitive Healthcare recently produced a report on addressing the healthcare staffing shortage. It is a sweeping report that touches on all aspects of healthcare staffing and the drivers of today’s shortages including aging patient population and burnout experienced by providers.  While the impact of staffing shortages on healthcare is significant, I do want to address the factor that will further affect healthcare organizations in the near future: our aging physician population.

In the physician space, many specialties including psychiatry, surgery and internal medicine, have an average age of 50 years old or higher. Therefore, many medical staffs have active member practicing well into their 60s.  A practice administrator once told me, “Physicians don’t plan their retirement. They just show up one day and say they are going to stop practicing at the end of the month.”  I’m sure many of you have experienced this and it is important to not be caught by unexpected retirements in key physician specialties such as primary care or surgery.  In many small to mid-sized hospitals, a couple of unexpected retirements could result in a domino effect of additional departures which would take years to correct.

As I tell many clients, when you begin a search, plan for the first day for that new physician to be a year from now and you probably have a pretty good estimate.  Also, COVID has accelerated the use of telehealth which is great, but it limits the population of potential physician candidates to see patients in your community.  My recommendation is to begin recruiting for those specialties well before you think you need to. We have clients actively interviewing and making offers to 2024 candidates so it is not too soon to start the process.

Also, I suggest changing your definition of a retention time frame for physicians.  We harken back to the days when a physician would hang his shingle and practice in one community for 30 years, that’s not the norm anymore. In a pursuit to find those candidates, people focus on younger candidates.  I say consider all qualified candidates. Many of of our experienced candidates want to practice for 3-5 more years while serving as mentors for your younger medical staff. 

Better to have a few too many physicians in the short term then caught with too few for the long term.

Categories
Uncategorized

Conley’s Corner First Post

Over the course of my career, I have had an opportunity to talk with over a thousand physicians regarding career choices. One bit of wisdom I tend to share with all candidates is set the contract aside for a moment and think about where you want to live, where you want to work and who do you want to work with. Generally, if you start with these elements, you are much more likely to have a long-term fit which is probably what you are looking for.

Get In Touch

Speaking with a Consultant about Provider Recruitment

Get In Touch

Speaking with a Recruiter about my job search

Senior Director of Recruiting

Jason Spiece

Jason Spiece brings over 20 years of recruiting and consultant experience to the team. Many of those years are in the healthcare industry working with a variety of levels of professionals from entry-level to executives. He has a passion for physician recruitment, which has been the cornerstone of his career and success in helping families find the right fit nationwide. Jason brings a unique approach to recruitment that starts with listening to the needs and motivations of his candidates to ensure the right match is found for his candidates and clients.

Jason grew up in central Michigan and graduated from the University of Toledo as a scholarship athlete where a strong work ethic helped launch his career in the right path. He is the father of two young daughters and resides in the north Georgia area. He loves the outdoors and takes advantage of a multitude of recreational activities year-round.

DVP of Business Development

Tim Smith

Tim Smith has over 20 years of sales and marketing experience with more than 10 years in the healthcare industry. His knowledge of the industry, enthusiasm for relationship building, and drive to always keep the client his priority, makes him an invaluable asset to our team.

Tim prides himself on consulting and places an emphasis on building long-lasting, professional relationships. Tim excels through one of our JDHA values of Servant Leadership where Tim truly puts the needs of his clients before all else. Establishing a strong rapport with each client and understanding the exact needs of each business relationship is where Tim shines.

Tim relocated to Texas from Chicago in 2007. On his off-time, Tim enjoys sharing time with his wife, their 2 dogs and cat, or catching a sports game. On the weekends, you can often find Tim working on his golf game or coaching Minor League and Arena football in the Dallas area.

Business Administrator

Catherine Bremer

Catherine Bremer is J.D. Hawkins & Associates’ Business Administrator with over 5 years of Operations experience, 3 of which are in the industry. Catherine began her career in Accounting then expanded her knowledge to Payroll, HR, and Business administrative duties just to name a few. Catherine has previously won awards such as the People’s Choice Award and Operations winner for Accountability.

As a Partner of J.D. Hawkins & Associates, Catherine is on board to bring the founders’ visions to life and ensure smooth operations behind-the-scenes while supporting her colleagues on the front lines.

Catherine was born and raised in East Dallas, Texas, and attended Sam Houston State University. Catherine and her husband, Blake, reside in north Dallas with their three children, two dogs, and bearded dragon. On the weekends, you can find the Bremers spending time with family at the lake fishing, swimming, or just hanging out outdoors.

VP of Business Development

Jeremy Schultz

Jeremy Schultz has 20+ years of experience in healthcare. He has a broad national background working with health systems, hospitals, physician practices, federally qualified health centers, behavioral health groups, and government facilities.

As a partner of J.D. Hawkins & Associates, Jeremy brings a proven ability to cultivate and sustain relationships with C-suite decision makers, physician leadership, and industry thought leaders. He is passionate about helping organizations develop and implement effective provider succession, retention, and recruiting protocols that are based on research, market analysis, and a thorough understanding of each client’s unique set of systems and processes.

Jeremy grew up in Cedar Rapids, IA and graduated from the University of Northern Iowa. Jeremy and his son live in the Dallas/Ft. Worth area where he enjoys supporting his son’s love of playing bass guitar at venues throughout the metroplex.

EXECUTIVE VP OF RECRUITING

Mark Conley

Mark Conley is an executive leader with over 20 years of physician search experience. Mark began his career as a recruiter and was recognized as the National Recruiter of the year in 2001 for Merritt Hawkins, ultimately being honored as a member of the Recruiting Hall of Fame. He also served as a Vice President of Recruiting, leading the Southeast Recruiting team, where he oversaw the completion of hundreds of search projects. Mark is an alumnus of Herman Miller Inc. where he learned a client-centric approach to business.

As a Partner of J.D. Hawkins & Associates, Mark provides advice to clients and providers on topics ranging from structuring compensation packages and physician search process to partnership agreements and physician retention strategies, just to name a few. Mark lives through our values of putting the client’s and provider’s needs first and thus works to consultatively understand any challenges they face and find the best solution to address these challenges.

Mr. Conley was born in and raised in Chicago as well as in Michigan. Mark is a graduate of Alma College and the University of Notre Dame and is an avid fan of all Irish sports teams (Go Irish!). He and his wife, Lisa, have a son and daughter, and live in Forsyth County Georgia. In his free time, Mark is very active with coaching and attending his son’s baseball, football, and basketball games as well as his daughter’s soccer and basketball games.

COO

Jason Reavis

Jason Reavis has been a recruiter and consultant since 2002. He brings a unique perspective gained from his experience in education, serving the social, emotional and mental health needs of students. Having successfully recruited over 100 physicians and midlevel providers in a variety of settings, Jason brings the energy, knowledge and experience needed to successfully identify and secure the right candidate.

As one of the founders of J.D. Hawkins & Associates, Jason recognizes and appreciates that the role of a recruiter is about building strong and lasting relationships based on trust, integrity and tenacity. He treats every client as if it were his only one and embodies the values we hold dear at JDHA.

Jason grew up in North Carolina, graduated from NC State University and has found himself always pulling for the underdog! His wife, Jennifer, was born and raised in Texas. They have a son and a daughter and just recently moved to the Phoenix metro after having lived in the Atlanta area for 18 years. On weekends, you can find Jason cheering on his daughter in musical theater and his son in baseball!

CEO

Troy Fowler

Troy Fowler is an executive leader and veteran physician recruiter with over 20 years of physician recruitment experience. Having won many physician “Recruiter of the Year” awards, he is an expert at filling the most difficult searches. Additionally, Mr. Fowler has overseen thousands of client searches, leading sizable teams of recruiters with Merritt Hawkins in the Midwest, Southwest, and West Coast divisions. He has also recruited to every state in the country with the exception of a few states in the Northeast. He will listen, clarify, and then efficiently create a recruitment plan of attack that is NOT one size fits all.

As a co-founder of J.D. Hawkins & Associates, his goal is to get back to “the every search is different, personalized approach that treats clients as partners not a number.” True servant leadership is what JDHA is founded on and will be the reason clients will choose JDHA over and over again.

Mr. Fowler was born in South Carolina and raised in a small town in Iowa. He and his wife Lucy have one son and live in the country just north of Dallas. In his free time, Troy is very active in the CrossFit community.

President Emeritus

John D. Hawkins

Mr. Hawkins has over 30 years’ experience in Healthcare Consulting and Recruiting, and is a nationally recognized leader in Healthcare Staffing. His expertise includes strategic and operational management in Physician Recruiting and Business Development.

For the past 25 years, Mr. Hawkins was a Senior Vice President for Merritt Hawkins, involved in the daily management of Business Development and Recruiting for the Northeast and Southeast regions. He has personally overseen more than 20,000 permanent clinician and executive search assignments nationally.

As co-founder and President Emeritus of J.D. Hawkins & Associates, Mr. Hawkins has been instrumental in developing the mission, vision and culture of the organization. JDHA is founded on the principles of service to others; putting their clients’, providers’ and community’s needs above their own.

Mr. Hawkins was born and raised in Miami, Florida. He served 3 years in the United States Marine Corps and currently resides in Atlanta. Mr. Hawkins and wife Kim have four children.